Skip to main content

Reports and complaints

A Works or Broken report tells the hub whether an applied set does its job on this network, and it feeds the set's score. A complaint tells the moderators about a problem with the set as published, and does not change the score.

Requirements​

  • For a report: the set is applied, and its strategy is unchanged since.
  • For a complaint: nothing. A set can be reported without being applied.

Steps​

  1. Apply the set and use the sites it covers for a while.
  2. When a site does not open, click Test on the card, see Testing an applied set. A site that fails both through b4 and around it is down or blocked outright, which says nothing about the set.
  3. Click Works or Broken on the card.

The pressed button stays marked, and its tooltip shows the date of the report. Clicking the other button replaces the report.

Works and broken​

The hub keeps one current report per router, strategy and network each week. A report counts for the network the hub sees the router on, so it shapes the score that routers on the same ISP and in the same country see first, see Reading the score.

On an edited set the buttons are disabled, because a report would not describe the published strategy. Reapply restores the published strategy and enables them again, see Updating and reapplying.

A report made while no hub answers is saved and goes out with the next sync. The status line on the Community page shows how many reports are waiting. They are kept for 30 days.

Complaints​

Report on a card or in Details opens a complaint, with a reason of up to 500 characters. Complaints are for:

  • a strategy that does not do what the title says;
  • targets the set has no reason to cover, such as a regexp: pattern under a narrow title;
  • a pin that points at an address that does not belong to the site;
  • a duplicate, or spam.

A set that does not work on this network gets a Broken report, not a complaint. Three complaints about one version, from routers on different networks, take it out of the catalogue without waiting for a moderator. A complaint made while no hub answers waits for the next sync, like a report.

Limits​

The hub accepts a limited number of shared sets, reports and complaints from one router a day. Some limits count per network, so a router new to the hub can be refused because other new routers on the same network came first that day. The hub operator sets the limits.

A record over a limit is refused with a message that names the limit and when it resets. Reports and complaints are saved and go out with a later sync. A shared set is not saved, and has to be published again once the limit resets.

When it does not work​

MessageMeaning
Apply the set first; reports are accepted only for sets in use.The set is not applied on this router.
Report saved; it goes out with the next sync.No hub answered, or a limit was reached. The report waits in the queue.
Could not send the report: ...The report was not sent. The message names the reason, such as a key the moderators banned.